메뉴로 건너 뛰기 내용으로 건너 뛰기
커뮤니티 COMMUNITY
제목 [Jin Bae] SAT Writing
1 Lecture_17_Writing Practice Test #5_01 1
작성자 cje*** 등록일 2021-01-13 오전 12:56:36

Hello, Mr.Bae.


I have a question on number1.

I want to check whether my thought for deleting D is on the right track. 

Is the reason why President have to be the essential clause because there could be many Thomas Jefferson? 

I know that Only writing President should be followed by an essential clause. However, I am not sure whether 'president' is necessary in the sentence. 

2021-01-13 오전 9:52:50

Hey student! =)

 

Great question!

 

When you have two noun phrases next to each other, you have to determine whether the 2nd noun phrase (not the 1st) is essential or nonessential. It is always the 2nd noun phrase that will receive 2 commas around it or 0 commas.

 

1st noun phrase = President

2nd noun phrase = Thomas Jefferson

 

So, to determine whether you place commas around Thomas Jefferson, look at the first noun phrase (president). Since this noun is general (there could be many presidents), Thomas Jefferson is essential (no commas).

 

However, if the first noun phrase said "the third U.S. President," there can only be "one" third president, right? So, Thomas Jefferson is now considered nonessential and should be surrounded by commas. (The third U.S. President, Thomas Jefferson, was great).

 

To help you out even further, I wrote some material on commas (essential/nonessential) that you might find helpful and attached it here.

 

I hope this helps!

 

Keep moving forward!

 

You got this!

Top