메뉴로 건너 뛰기 내용으로 건너 뛰기
커뮤니티 COMMUNITY
제목 [Kevyn Lee] Kevyn Lee 토플 질문
케. 토플/Kevynized TOFEL for the TOP 0.001% Reading Series 1 (34 강 완성)_SET 02 09
작성자 mar*** 등록일 2019-07-04 오전 11:35:48

안녕하세요! 저는 케빈 선생님의 강의를 듣고 있는 학생인데 선생님의 강의 중에서 Lesson 9의 "Desert Formation", paragraph 9에 대해서 질문이 있어서 이렇게 수업게시판에 글을 올려요. (이제부터 영어로 말할게요)


In question 8, it askes about the reason why the ground's absorption of excess water is a factor in desertification. In paragraph 9, it says that the major human cause of desertification is soil salinization resulting from overirrigation, since when over irrigation occurs, the water table rises along with salt, and when the water evaporates because of the heat, the salt remains, which blocks air and water from reaching the underlying soil.


In your lecture, you have stated that the answer for question 8 is D. Bring salts to the surface, and I understand that this is a fact stated in the passage. However, I believe that the salt is not the direct reason why excess water is a factor in desertification, the result of the salt coming up is, which makes the answer A. Interfere with the irrigation of land.


Could you please explain why A. is not the answer? I get that D is a fact, but I need an explanation which could clarify that A is wrong and D is right. Thank you!

2019-07-08 오후 7:15:42
Par: 6 : Four specificactivities have been identified as major contributors to the desertificationprocesses: overcultivation, overgrazing, firewood gathering, andoverirrigation.

 

 

 

The final major human cause ofdesertification is soil salinization resulting from overirrigation. Excesswater from irrigation sinks down into the water table. If no drainage systemexists, the water table rises, bringing dissolved salts to the surface. Thewater evaporates and the salts are left behind, creating a white crustal layerthat prevents air and water from reaching the underlying soil.

According to paragraph9, the ground’s absorption of excess water is a factor in desertification because it can .........

 

 

Okay I get what you are saying and you do have a point, but you are CLEARLY not reading the choice A carefully, or you are not precisely thinking about WHY irrigation is mentioned in the first place.

 

The reason for desertification is NOT BECAUSE IT INTERFERES WITH irrigation.

The passage CLEARLY SAID overirrigation. I also attached part of paragraph 6 so that you understand that this is an example of human activity.

Now, BECAUSE of human activity (overirrigation), there is too much water, and because there is too much water without the appropriate drainage system, the water comes back up with salt.

 

So if you think about it, even if you DID WANT TO SAY THAT OPTION A is anything close to being the answer, it has to say OVERIRRIGATION, not INTERFERING WITH THE IRRIGATION.

To put it simply, the reason for desertification is because of OVERIRRIGATION. (and salt rising to the surface is BECAUSE OF overirrigation)

Irrigation was never interrupted in the first place.

 

Hope this helps you~

 

 

 

Top